Cruise Lines Compared

Mainstream Cruise Lines Ranked

Updated March 9, 20268 min readBy the Cruise Compass editors

Affiliate disclosure: Cruise Compass is reader-supported. When you book through our CruiseDirect links we may earn a commission at no additional cost to you. Read more.

The short answer

Mainstream cruise lines ranked include Carnival, Royal Caribbean and Norwegian.

Mainstream cruise lines offer a great balance of price and experience, with typical prices ranging from $800 to $2,000 per person for a 7-night cruise, depending on the time of year and itinerary, and often include a wide range of onboard activities and entertainment options, such as rock climbing walls and Broadway shows, as well as multiple dining venues and bars, with some lines offering more inclusive drink packages and Wi-Fi than others.

In this article, we will compare the top mainstream cruise lines, including Carnival, Royal Caribbean, Norwegian, MSC and Costa, and evaluate their strengths and weaknesses in areas such as cabin quality, food, entertainment, crowd and value, to help you make an informed decision for your next cruise, whether you are looking for a family-friendly vacation or a romantic getaway, and considering factors such as budget, destination and time of year.

Ready to price it up?Check current sailings and fares on CruiseDirect before you commit to a cruise line.

Compare prices →

Cabin Quality and Amenities

When it comes to cabin quality, some mainstream cruise lines stand out from the rest, such as Royal Caribbean's Oasis-class ships, which offer luxurious suites with private balconies and whirlpools, and typical prices for these cabins range from $2,000 to $5,000 per person for a 7-night cruise, depending on the time of year and itinerary, while other lines, such as Carnival, offer more budget-friendly options, with interior cabins starting at around $800 per person for a 7-night cruise, and often include amenities such as flat-screen TVs and minibars.

However, it's worth noting that cabin quality can vary significantly within each line, and even on the same ship, with higher deck numbers and more centrally located cabins typically commanding higher prices, and some lines, such as Norwegian, offer more flexible cabin categories, such as their popular studio cabins for solo travelers, which can be a great value for those traveling alone, with prices starting at around $1,000 per person for a 7-night cruise.

Royal Caribbean's Oasis-class ships offer luxurious suites
Carnival's interior cabins start at around $800 per person
Norwegian's studio cabins for solo travelers start at around $1,000 per person

Dining Options and Quality

Mainstream cruise lines have made significant improvements to their dining options in recent years, with many lines now offering a wide range of specialty restaurants, such as steakhouses and Italian restaurants, and some lines, such as MSC, offering more inclusive dining packages, which can be a great value for those who want to try multiple restaurants, with typical prices ranging from $20 to $50 per person per meal, depending on the restaurant and menu, and some lines, such as Royal Caribbean, offering more flexible dining options, such as their My Time Dining program, which allows passengers to dine at any time between 6pm and 9:30pm.

However, it's worth noting that dining quality can vary significantly within each line, and even on the same ship, with some lines, such as Carnival, offering more casual, buffet-style dining options, which can be a great value for families and groups, but may not be as appealing to those looking for a more upscale dining experience, and some lines, such as Norwegian, offering more upscale dining options, such as their popular Cagney's steakhouse, which offers high-quality steaks and seafood, but may come at an additional cost, with typical prices ranging from $30 to $50 per person per meal.

MSC offers more inclusive dining packages
Royal Caribbean's My Time Dining program offers flexible dining options
Carnival's buffet-style dining options are great for families and groups
Norwegian's Cagney's steakhouse offers high-quality steaks and seafood

Entertainment and Activities

Mainstream cruise lines offer a wide range of entertainment and activities, from Broadway shows and live music venues to rock climbing walls and water parks, and some lines, such as Royal Caribbean, offer more innovative and high-tech entertainment options, such as their popular robot bartenders and virtual reality experiences, which can be a great value for those looking for a more modern and tech-savvy cruise experience, with typical prices ranging from $100 to $300 per person for a 7-night cruise, depending on the line and itinerary, and some lines, such as Carnival, offering more family-friendly activities, such as their popular water parks and kids' clubs, which can be a great value for families and groups.

However, it's worth noting that entertainment and activity options can vary significantly within each line, and even on the same ship, with some lines, such as Norwegian, offering more adult-oriented activities, such as their popular casino and nightclub, which can be a great value for those looking for a more vibrant and energetic cruise experience, but may not be as appealing to families and groups, and some lines, such as MSC, offering more cultural and educational activities, such as their popular wine tastings and cooking demonstrations, which can be a great value for those looking for a more sophisticated and enriching cruise experience.

Royal Caribbean offers innovative and high-tech entertainment options
Carnival offers family-friendly activities, such as water parks and kids' clubs
Norwegian offers adult-oriented activities, such as casinos and nightclubs
MSC offers cultural and educational activities, such as wine tastings and cooking demonstrations

Pricing up cruise lines compared?

Once you know what you want, the only way to know what it costs is to check live fares. CruiseDirect compares sailings across all the major cruise lines in a single search.

Search cruise deals →

We may earn a commission if you book through this link, at no extra cost to you. It helps keep these guides free.

Crowd and Demographics

Mainstream cruise lines can vary significantly in terms of crowd and demographics, with some lines, such as Carnival, catering more to families and groups, and offering a more lively and energetic atmosphere, with typical prices ranging from $800 to $2,000 per person for a 7-night cruise, depending on the time of year and itinerary, and some lines, such as Royal Caribbean, catering more to couples and solo travelers, and offering a more upscale and sophisticated atmosphere, with typical prices ranging from $1,000 to $3,000 per person for a 7-night cruise, depending on the time of year and itinerary.

However, it's worth noting that crowd and demographics can vary significantly within each line, and even on the same ship, with some lines, such as Norwegian, offering more flexible and adaptable cruise experiences, which can be a great value for those who want to try a variety of different activities and entertainment options, and some lines, such as MSC, offering more traditional and formal cruise experiences, which can be a great value for those who want a more classic and elegant cruise experience.

Carnival caters more to families and groups
Royal Caribbean caters more to couples and solo travelers
Norwegian offers flexible and adaptable cruise experiences
MSC offers traditional and formal cruise experiences

Value and Inclusivity

Mainstream cruise lines can vary significantly in terms of value and inclusivity, with some lines, such as Carnival, offering more inclusive pricing and packaging, which can be a great value for those who want to try a variety of different activities and entertainment options, with typical prices ranging from $800 to $2,000 per person for a 7-night cruise, depending on the time of year and itinerary, and some lines, such as Royal Caribbean, offering more upscale and premium experiences, which can be a great value for those who want a more luxurious and sophisticated cruise experience, with typical prices ranging from $1,000 to $3,000 per person for a 7-night cruise, depending on the time of year and itinerary.

However, it's worth noting that value and inclusivity can vary significantly within each line, and even on the same ship, with some lines, such as Norwegian, offering more flexible and adaptable pricing and packaging, which can be a great value for those who want to try a variety of different activities and entertainment options, and some lines, such as MSC, offering more traditional and formal pricing and packaging, which can be a great value for those who want a more classic and elegant cruise experience.

Carnival offers more inclusive pricing and packaging
Royal Caribbean offers upscale and premium experiences
Norwegian offers flexible and adaptable pricing and packaging
MSC offers traditional and formal pricing and packaging

Destination and Itinerary

Mainstream cruise lines offer a wide range of destinations and itineraries, from the Caribbean and Bahamas to Europe and Alaska, and some lines, such as Royal Caribbean, offer more exotic and off-the-beaten-path destinations, such as their popular cruises to the Middle East and Asia, which can be a great value for those who want to experience new and exciting cultures, with typical prices ranging from $1,000 to $3,000 per person for a 7-night cruise, depending on the time of year and itinerary, and some lines, such as Carnival, offering more traditional and classic destinations, such as their popular cruises to the Caribbean and Mexico, which can be a great value for those who want a more relaxing and laid-back cruise experience.

However, it's worth noting that destination and itinerary can vary significantly within each line, and even on the same ship, with some lines, such as Norwegian, offering more flexible and adaptable itineraries, which can be a great value for those who want to try a variety of different destinations and experiences, and some lines, such as MSC, offering more traditional and formal itineraries, which can be a great value for those who want a more classic and elegant cruise experience.

Royal Caribbean offers exotic and off-the-beaten-path destinations
Carnival offers traditional and classic destinations
Norwegian offers flexible and adaptable itineraries
MSC offers traditional and formal itineraries

Key takeaways

Mainstream cruise lines offer a great balance of price and experience
Cabin quality and amenities can vary significantly within each line
Dining options and quality can vary significantly within each line
Entertainment and activities can vary significantly within each line

Where to book this cruise

When booking a mainstream cruise, it's a good idea to research and compare different lines and itineraries to find the best fit for your budget and preferences, and to consider factors such as cabin category, dining options, and entertainment activities, and to compare current sailings and prices on CruiseDirect before booking, to ensure you get the best value for your money, and to also consider any additional costs or fees, such as gratuities and drink packages, to make sure you have a complete and accurate picture of the total cost of your cruise.

Check today's fares on CruiseDirect

Compare every major cruise line side by side, filter by date, port and cabin type, and see the real price before you commit. Searching costs nothing.

Search CruiseDirect deals →

We may earn a commission if you book through this link, at no extra cost to you. It helps keep these guides free.

Frequently asked questions

What is the best mainstream cruise line for families?

Carnival is a great option for families, with a wide range of family-friendly activities and amenities, such as water parks and kids' clubs.

What is the most luxurious mainstream cruise line?

Royal Caribbean is known for its luxurious and upscale amenities, such as its popular Oasis-class ships and upscale dining options.

What is the best mainstream cruise line for solo travelers?

Norwegian is a great option for solo travelers, with a wide range of studio cabins and solo-friendly activities and amenities, such as their popular solo travelers' program.

What is the best mainstream cruise line for destination immersion?

MSC is a great option for destination immersion, with a wide range of itineraries and shore excursions that allow passengers to experience local cultures and destinations, such as their popular Mediterranean cruises.

What is the best mainstream cruise line for value?

Carnival is a great option for value, with a wide range of affordable cabin categories and pricing options, such as their popular interior cabins and inclusive drink packages.